“Disgusting Treachery and Negligence”
The Mercury reported the loss of the Planter under that headline, and did not name Robert Smalls — he is “four or five of her colored crew.” Its anger went to the three white officers who had gone ashore for the night; Relyea, Smith and Pitcher were arrested for court-martial. The paper still could not help printing the detail that makes the story: the Planter blew her whistle passing Fort Sumter, was seen plainly, was logged as the guard boat — and “on this trip did not turn.”
Charleston Mercury, 14 May 1862, p. 2, “Disgusting Treachery and Negligence”